I didn’t know how to go into this album. Colors is my all time favorite album, and to expect Between the Buried and Me to create another masterpiece of equal quality would simply be too much to expect. I tried to keep my expectations low, though while listening to the album I realized I didn’t really need to. The Great Misdirect is not in any way a rehash of Colors and is instead a completely different beast. Is it better? Ultimately, no. But that point is almost irrelevant, as Between the Buried and Me yet again has written a wonderful album that fuses many different unique sounds into a cohesive whole.
That album opens up slowly with “Mirrors”, a very jazzy intro. It’s a nice little piece that sets the stage but at only three minutes it’s hard to look at it anything more than just that. “Obfuscation” brings the more standard BTBAM sound back into the fold, and is a solid piece that for the most part doesn’t cover any new territory but is enjoyable, nevertheless. The guitar solo/bass groove from around 5:00 – 6:30 is the highlight of the song for me, which definitely reflects an old-school prog influence. Overall the album has a decent start, and it only gets better.
“Disease, Injury, Madness”, the third track of the album, is without a doubt the best song of the album that ranks among some of the band’s best work. The song really showcases how much BTBAM’s writing has evolved over the years, and is some of their most mature work to date. They experiment with very atmospheric interludes, soft rock verses, bluesy sections, classical sounding guitar work, and of course their typical hardcore-influenced brand of metal.”Fossil Genera – A Feed from Cloud Mountain” is also a great song that feeds off of the momentum from the previous track. The band once again flips through a bunch of different sounds before landing on a very relaxing, melodic section at around 9 minutes that builds up to a very satisfying conclusion.
“Desert Song” is a very cool folky sounding song that came a bit out of left field but I found myself enjoying quite a bit. At this point it’s quite obvious that this album is a lot less heavier than any of there other releases, with Tommy’s clean voice being used perhaps even more frequently than the shouts/growls. It’s essentially a straight up progressive rock song, but it’s one of my favorite sections of the album.
“Swim to the Moon” acts as the ‘epic closer’ and is BTBAM’s longest track to date at over 17 minutes long. It starts off in excellent fashion with some wonderful guitar work and interesting synth work. Unfortunately the song loses steam and goes through a number of sections that simply fail to excite. It does pick up again though around the 10 minute mark and ends strongly.
Perhaps the biggest flaw of the album, in my opinion, is a loss of focus. At times, the longer tracks feel like they’re not building up or progressing towards anything, and instead are just flowing along. The result is the songs feel less memorable than they probably should. The album’s biggest strength, on the other hand, is that it really takes the band to places they haven’t been before and shows them exploring with a lot of new ideas. It’s not a rehash of Colors, which is good, because I don’t think they could have pulled that off.
So there you have it. I’m sure opinions of this will be across the board. Some will probably find it to be as amazing if not more so than Colors while others will come away greatly disappointed by the changes in direction. And of course, the haters will still be hatin’. For me personally, I would be lying if I said I wasn’t slightly disappointed. However, I also recognize that this is partly due to comparing it to the masterpiece Colors, because when examining The Great Misdirect on its own merits, it’s certainly a great album that all fans should enjoy.
Rating: 4/5
- Mirrors [3:37]
- Obfuscation [9:15]
- Disease, Injury, Madness [11:02]
- Fossil Genera – A Feed from Cloud Mountain [12:10]
- Desert of Song [5:33]
- Swim to the Moon [17:53]