After the 2002 release of Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence, a noticeable downward trend started to appear in Dream Theater’s releases. By the time Systematic Chaos was released in 2007, the fan base had grown very polarized with the band and felt that by attempting to be more “metal” and appeal to a larger audience, they had lost what had made them so special in the first place. Sure, they’re much more popular now than they were 10 years ago, but was it worth the cost of losing the fans that had gotten them so far in the first place? Understandably, Dream Theater was under a lot of pressure to release a great album, and for the first time in a while, they needed to prove something to their audience – that they could still write incredible compositions.
Enter Black Clouds & Silver Linings. As soon as the tracklist was announced, one could tell that Dream Theater were changing things up, with an album of only 6 tracks (and only 2 of them under 10 minutes). But as the fans know, quantity doesn’t always equal quality, so this in itself didn’t say much about the music. However it did say that perhaps Dream Theater would stop caring so much about writing radio friendly singles (like “Forsaken” and “Constant Motion” on Systematic Chaos) and more about writing progressive songs they are known for.
The album has a bit of a rocky start. The first minute or so contains some sound effects and some cheesy sounding keyboard from Rudess, but once the full band comes in “A Nightmare to Remember” really starts, and the song takes a sharp turn for the better. The song both contains some heavy parts (among the heaviest DT has recorded), and some nice mellower parts as well. The song really gets better as it goes, and unlike their previous three albums it doesn’t sound like the song just exists as a platform for solos, but instead it seems like the focus has shifted back towards composition (which most fans will agree is for the better). Not to say that there isn’t any soloing going on at all, but for the most part it feels more concise and fits well into the confines of the song. The only real annoyances are Mike Portnoy’s singing/growling (please, just stop trying) and some corny keyboard parts. Overall, “A Nightmare to Remember” is nowhere near the best song Dream Theater has recorded, but it does start the album off on the right foot.
The next track is the first single from the album, “A Rite of Passage”, the only song I had listened to before the album came out. It’s certainly much better than the singles from Systematic Chaos and has a very infections main riff, along with memorable singing from LaBrie. At times it sound a little silly, but it makes up for it with a sense of fun that’s not common in their music. If you didn’t find yourself at least bobbing your head to this song, you should probably just stop listening now.
Now “Wither” is the first real surprise of the album. This sounds direct from Falling Into Infinity (with a modern touch), which is a real treat for me since I consider it their most underrated album. It’s not at all what I would expect from a Dream Theater song – which is exactly why I’m liking it so much. Lately they’ve become a bit predictable, but I definitely didn’t see this coming. It’s basically a power ballad with Dream Theater’s signature touch – a real stadium rock song. I could see this song turning off both metalheads and people listening for their virtuosity (and combined that makes up pretty much their whole fanbase), but I really enjoyed the change of pace.
…and just like as if Dream Theater knew their last song might turn some people off, “The Shattered Fortress” comes roaring in with a lot of crunch and some great metal riffs. For those who don’t know, it’s the last song in Portnoy’s AA suite, which chronicles his struggle to give up alcohol after realizing he was an alcoholic, with one song from the suite appearing on each of their last albums dating back to Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence. I’ve heard some people complaining that this song reuses some riffs from previous songs in the series, but all I have to say is, “duh!”. It’s a suite – the music is all interconnected as if it was one piece of work. Not only that, but it’s the finale, so I fully would have expected them to bring back a lot of themes from the earlier songs. While listening to the song, it doesn’t sound like they just “copy-pasted” the parts together, but instead it flows together rather seamlessly. I can understand why people are a bit disappointed that over half the song is familiar, but I can’t say it honestly bothered me too much as it’s all in a different context and hearing it in a new light made the material feel new.
Holy shit. That’s all I have to say about “The Best of Times”. The first couple minutes are a tad too melodramatic, but as the electric guitar comes in the song morphs into something that would not be out of place on Images & Words or Awake (though with a more modern-DT sound). The melodramtic-ness I mentioned in the beginning does come back into the song in a few parts, but for the most part it’s a great Dream Theater song and a fitting tribute to Mike Portnoy’s late father.
As awesome as “The Best of Times” is, “The Count of Tuscany” rivals it in quality. Yes, the lyrics are laughable, but musically this is very impressive. The first couple minutes and the last ~8 minutes are the best because they show, as I’ve mentioned before, a great sense of composition instead of just pure shredding. I read a review comparing it to Rush, and I definitely feel that influence here.
Black Clouds & Silver Linings is interesting because it’s not an attempt to go back to the sound of the Images & Words era that fans so cherish, but instead it tries to take what was so great about those albums and fuse it with their modern metal-ish sound. Does it always work? Well there are certainly moments on here that I could have done without, but as a whole I would say it’s a step in the right direction and definitely a reversal of the downward trend they were recently on. Dream Theater’s firing on all cylinders here – and while I know I’ve been comparing this album to past releases the whole time my final words are just to take this album for what it is. Dream Theater is never releasing another Images & Words, or another Awake, or even another Metropolis, Pt. 2, so just listen to this album expecting something different and you should find yourself enjoying it.
Rating: 4/5
Tracklist:
- A Nightmare to Remember [16:11]
- A Rite of Passage [8:36]
- Wither [5:26]
- The Shattered Fortress [12:49]
- The Best of Times [13:09]
- The Count of Tuscany [19:16]