It’s hard to be unbiased here. I mean just from looking at the source material, unless BTBAM had really screwed up somehow, there was no way this wasn’t going to be awesome. That being said, this DVD surpassed my already very high expectations to deliver a truly exciting two hour concert. But allow me to back up for a minute…
Between the Buried and Me’s 2007 album, “Colors” is one of my all time favorite albums. There is no experience quite like it. It’s one absolutely breathtaking 64 minute song that often transcends genres (though it would most easily be categorized as progressive metal). “Colors_LIVE”, as the title suggests, is a concert taped and recorded that included two sets, the first set being the whole “Colors” album/song, while the second set includes songs from their first three albums as voted on by the fans.
Any performing musician understands that, logically, the longer and more technical a song is the harder it will be to perform live. That makes a near flawless performance of an extremely technical hour long song incredibly impressive. There are literally two, ten second breaks throughout the song to catch a breath. Unbelievably, I can honestly say that I did not catch any mistakes throughout the entire performance. I’m sure some very observant and/or nitpicks will find some mistakes, but sounds practically as good as the studio. Even if the DVD just captured just this first set, it would still be more than worth picking up.
Luckily for us, however, “Colors” only makes up for half of the show. The second set is almost as exciting as the first (though, honestly, nothing could ever top Colors). The fans did a good job of choosing the songs, for the band plays through most of their classics. “Mordecai”, “Selkies: The Endless Obsession”, “Aspirations”, “Backwards Marathon” and more…you couldn’t ask for a much better setlist.
It’s not just the music itself that is impressive, I found that the DVD was very well shot, much better than I was expecting. There’s something about the way the concert was filmed that gives it a very intimate feeling. For almost the entire performance of the first set, the crowd is never shown. The filmmakers (wisely) decided to focus almost entirely on the band. The way the concert was shot is very effective and makes the viewing experience not quite like any other live DVD I’ve ever seen. The concert almost has a certain warmth to it, which is certainly an odd way to describe a progressive death metal concert but it’s honestly the only word that comes to mind.
If an amazing two hour DVD wasn’t enough, the package also includes a CD which contains the audio of the first set, and the DVD comes with a few features such as a short documentary. None of the extras are really essential, but they do add to the value of the package. I was also impressed with the packaging. The album art looked a little cheesy online but actually looked quite nice in my hands.
I can say with all honesty this is the best live DVD I own. There’s just some intangible feeling I had when watching it that I’ve never felt while watching a live concert before. As I said in the beginning, it would have been impossible for this to have been bad due to the the source material, but this DVD exceeded my already high expectations to deliver a truly powerful live experience. I’ve spent hours asking myself if this really deserves the rating I’m giving it, but I can’t think of a reason why it shouldn’t. Therefore, I give “Colors_LIVE” a perfect 5/5. I truly have never seen a DVD like this before.
Rating: 5/5
Setlist:
1. Foam Born (a): The Backtrack
2. Foam Born (b): The Decade of Statues
3. Informal Gluttony
4. Sun of Nothing
5. Ants of the Sky
6. Prequel to the Sequel
7. Viridian
8. White Walls
9. Mordecai
10. Shevanel Cut a Flip
11. Backwards Marathon
12. Ad a Dglgmut
13. Aspirations
14. Selkies: The Endless Obsession